AFTERNOON TEA REVIEWS

Complete List of Every Afternoon Tea in New York City

A list of every single afternoon tea in New York City. Find reviews and ratings by setting, service, tea, and most importantly, the food.


NYC Afternoon Tea Checklist

Join my free email list to get this NYC afternoon tea checklist!



★★★★★

Baccarat Hotel is offering the best and my favorite afternoon tea in New York City right now. With a unique selection of afternoon teas from the classic to the Turkish Tea, they’re doing everything right.

It’s worth the splurge.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★★

A hidden gem, the Pembroke Room inside The Lowell Hotel offers a solid afternoon tea service. Perfect for those leisurely afternoons sipping tea in a quiet and demure setting for a couple of hours with a good friend and good conversation.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★★

A posh setting for afternoon tea in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, The St. Regis New York with its gorgeous painted ceiling and plush seats make this an afternoon tea worth every penny.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

Tea at The Plaza is quintessential New York — a must if you’re an afternoon tea fan. Is it worth the money and the hype? Hmmm, that’s a whole other story.

SEE FULL REVIEW

The savories, the scones, and the sweets are excellent at the Four Seasons Hotel New York. Then why the 4 stars? Read on to see my full review.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

Overlooking Central Park, BG Restaurant inside the super luxury Bergdorf Goodman department store has a three course afternoon tea service at $45 per person that’s more affordable than ones offered at high-end hotels.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

A unique afternoon tea tucked inside a speakeasy, Garfunkel’s has afternoon tea for $40, which is a rare find. Made and served with care, this one is a new addition to the afternoon tea scene that I can recommend.

Afternoon tea at Garfunkel’s is under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

Mini EVERYTHING and served on a three-tiered tray, The Pierre does a very good afternoon tea. I also like their Tiffin Tea which is an Indian take on afternoon tea.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

Adorable and tasty savories are a highlight at The Peninsula’s afternoon tea. A luxury hotel in Midtown Manhattan, the tea service here is a pretty solid one.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★★☆

Oh, the dining room at The Russian Tea Room is spectacular! The bright reds and the deep green transports you away to another place. It’s a feast for the eyes — but is the tea service?

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

The Whitby Hotel is a sister hotel to the Crosby Street Hotel and you’ll get a very similar vibe in each of the hotel’s restaurants where afternoon tea is served. Both hotels have a very pretty setting for tea and The Whitby Hotel’s back room is especially perfect for tea.

The Whitby Hotel serves afternoon tea all day and it’s under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

The Crosby Street Hotel’s Crosby Bar is very very pretty and it’s a good place for afternoon tea downtown since there are less options for tea below 14th Street. The tea service is reasonable for the price.

The Crosby Street Hotel serves afternoon tea all day and it’s under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

Bosie is a cute tea spot in the West Village that does a three-tiered tray of afternoon tea for a reasonable price. Very casual and great alternative for an afternoon snack.

Bosie’s afternoon tea is under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

Lady Mendl’s is a quaint afternoon tea experience near Gramercy Park inside a charming brownstone. It’s like having tea with your grandmother. They do a multi-course afternoon tea instead of the usual three and they bring out each course separately so no three-tiered tray here.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

King’s Carriage House on the Upper East Side is a townhouse that has been converted to a restaurant. They do the least expensive and most affordable afternoon tea in NYC at the moment at under $30. It’s not the fanciest, but it’s good for the price.

King’s Carriage House does afternoon tea for under $30 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

Tea & Sympathy is a casual afternoon tea inside a West Village restaurant that serves British comfort food. You won’t find any dainty finger foods but hearty bites cut into manageable pieces. Scones here are fantastic.

Afternoon tea at Tea & Sympathy is under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

Afternoon tea at The Morgan Library’s cafe keeps changing over the years. The very first time I went years ago, it was excellent but over the years the offering has been a little less impressive but either way, the price is reasonable and a good option when visiting the museum.

The Morgan does afternoon tea for $30 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★★☆☆

Afternoon tea is served daily at the Plaza Athénée on the Upper East Side. Three courses come out on a three-tiered tray alongside a pot of tea.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★☆☆☆

Dipping into a rating of two stars, Chanson bakery in Flatiron has a wonderful selection of baked good but unfortunately the afternoon tea is a disappointment. It seems purely a money-grab and an afterthought although the presentation is adorable.

Chanson’s afternoon tea is under $30 per person.

Continue Reading
★★☆☆☆

Scones the size of your head, Alice’s Tea Cup is a restaurant with a few locations that is all about tea. Kids and parents seem to love it, although it’s not my *ahem* cup of tea.

Alice’s Tea Cup serves afternoon tea for under $50 per person.

SEE FULL REVIEW
★★☆☆☆

I used to really like the tea at The Carlyle but they have gone down in quality over the years. The setting is still very very nice but the tea sandwiches were a huge letdown.

SEE FULL REVIEW
AFTERNOON TEA – NOT YET REVIEWED

American Girl Cafe
Blank Slate Tea
BlueBird London NYC
Four Seasons Hotel New York
Lillie’s Times Square

Marie Belle
Patisserie Fouet

Tiffany & Co.

 

MORE AFTERNOON TEA REVIEWS
 
 

NYC Afternoon Tea Checklist

Join my free email list to get this NYC afternoon tea checklist!